fatwa request: wafa al wa'd

Assalamu alaykum wa rahmatullah,I hope this message finds you well.

Question (Fatwa Request):I am a woman who was explicitly promised marriage by a man. He privately raised the issue of polygamy with me and deliberately maintained an ongoing relationship during almost 3 years that included reassurance, emotional attachment, and repeated expressions of commitment. He did so while having full knowledge that I am alone, socially and emotionally vulnerable, and without family or external support.

After his intention was revealed to his first wife and a major upheaval occurred in his family life, he did not terminate the relationship. On the contrary, he continued contact with me for an extended period, used me as an emotional outlet, spoke to me extensively about his personal pain, losses, and distress, and relied on me for emotional support — while systematically neglecting, minimizing, or ignoring the psychological harm and anguish I was experiencing.

Despite my explicit expressions of despair, emotional exhaustion, and inability to cope, he later ended the relationship abruptly and cut off all contact.

He justified his withdrawal by stating that his life had previously been stable with his first wife and that he was therefore capable of marrying me at that time, but that after the collapse of his family situation, he was no longer able. He further invoked divine decree (al-qadar) to frame the failure of the marriage as something “written” by Allah.

Throughout this process, he focused exclusively on the suffering of his first family and his own pain, while showing no regard for the harm inflicted upon me, despite his prior knowledge of my vulnerability and dependence.

My questions are as follows:In Islamic law, does a promise of marriage, followed by sustained emotional attachment and reassurance, create a binding moral and religious responsibility, particularly when the man knows the woman is vulnerable and without any support?

Is it permissible for a man to maintain emotional contact with a woman after a major family crisis, to rely on her as emotional support, give her hope, and then withdraw abruptly without assuming responsibility for the harm caused?

Does invoking al-qadar constitute a valid Islamic justification for abandoning a promise and evading accountability for actions that were taken by choice and caused foreseeable harm?

According to Islamic principles of amānah (trust), ḍarar (harm), and accountability, what is the ruling on such conduct, and what obligations — if any — remain upon this man before Allah?

Jazakum Allahu khayran for your time,

understanding, and guidance.

 

بِسْمِ اللهِ الرَّحْمٰنِ الرَّحِيْمِ
الجواب وباللہ التوفیق
Promises hold great importance in Islam. Fulfilling one’s promise is a sign of the perfection of faith, while breaking promises is a characteristic of hypocrites. Therefore, whenever a promise is made—whether to another person or to Allah Almighty—one should make every possible effort to fulfill it. Going back on a promise is not permissible, either Islamically or morally. The Holy Qur’an commands the fulfillment of promises. Allah تعالى says: “And fulfill the covenant; indeed, the covenant will be questioned about.” (Surah Al-Isra, 17:34) The Prophet ﷺ said: “There is no faith for the one who does not uphold trust, and there is no religion for the one who does not fulfill his promise.” (Musnad Ahmad ibn Hanbal, Vol. 19, p. 376) Therefore, it is the responsibility of a person to honor their promise. However, if a person does not fulfill a promise, they cannot be compelled to do so. If a promise is not fulfilled due to a legitimate Shariah-based excuse, there is no sin. But breaking a promise without any valid excuse may lead to accountability. It is also necessary to clarify here that before marriage, engaging in such communication while being non-mahram (strangers) was not permissible in Shariah. One should repent and seek forgiveness for this and avoid such conduct in the future as well. As for using destiny (taqdeer) as an excuse, that is also incorrect. From a Shariah perspective, no financial penalty or compensation becomes obligatory for breaking a promise. You should exercise patience and pray to Allah Almighty for a suitable match. It is possible that not marrying this person may, in fact, be better for you.

بسم اللہ الرحمن الرحیم

الجواب و باللہ التوفیق: وعدہ  کی اسلام میں بڑی اہمیت ہے، وعدہ کی پاس داری ایمان کے کمال کی نشانی ہے، اور وعدہ خلافی  کی عادت منافقین  کا شیوہ ہے؛ اس لیے جب وعدہ کیا جائے ،  خواہ انسان سے ہو خواہ اللہ جل شانہ سے تو حتی الامکان اسے پورا کرنے کی کوشش کی جائے، اس سے مکرنا شرعا اور اخلاقا درست نہیں ہے،قرآن پاک میں وعدہ کو پورا کرنے  کا حکم دیاگیا ،

 اللہ تعالی کا ارشاد ہے :

"وَأَوْفُوْا بِٱلْعَهْدِ إِنَّ ٱلْعَهْدَ كَانَ مَسْـُٔولًا."(الإسراء: 34)

ترجمہ :"اور عہد کو پورا کیا کرو ، بے شک  عہد کی باز پرس ہونے والی ہے ۔"

وَأَوْفُوْا بِالْعَهْدِ إِنَّ الْعَهْدَ كَانَ مَسُْٔولًا  (الآیۃ 34)

ترجمہ: اور عہدوں  کو پورا کرو بے شک عہدوں کے بارے میں پوچھا جائے  گا۔

نبی کریم ﷺ نے فرمایا :

" لا إيمان لمن لا أمانة له، ولا دين لمن ‌لا ‌عهد ‌له." (مسند احمد بن حنبل: 19،ص:376)

جس شخص میں امانت کی پاسداری نہیں اس کا کوئی ایمان نہیں اور جس شخص میں وعد ہ کی پاسداری نہیں اس  کا  کوئی ایمان نہیں۔"

بناء بریں اس   شخص کی ذمہ  داری ہے کہ اپنا وعدہ نبھائے ،لیکن اگر وہ نہیں نبھاتا ہے تو اس پر ا س کو مجبور نہیں کیا جاسکتا ۔اگر کسی شرعی عذر  کی وجہ سے وعدہ نہ نبھایاجائے تو گناہ  نہیں ہوگا،بلاعذر وعدہ کی خلاف ورزی  کی صورت میں مواخذہ  ہوسکتا ہے۔

یہاں اس بات کی وضاحت ضروری ہےکہ نکاح سے قبل آپ  حضرات کا محرم اور اجنبی ہوتے ہوئے اس طرح بات چیت کرنا   شرعا جائز نہیں تھا ،اس سے توبہ واستغفار کریں ،اورا ٓئندہ بھی  اس سے اجتناب کریں۔

رہا تقدیر کا سہارا لینا وہ بھی درست نہیں ہے اور  شرعی اعتبار سے وعدہ کی خلاف ورزی پر کوئی تاوان لازم  نہیں ہوتا ہے،، آپ صبر کریں ، مناسب رشتے کے لئے  حق تعالیٰ سے دعا کریں ،ہوسکتا ہے کہ آپ سے نکاح نہ ہونے میں ہی آپ کے لئے بہتری ہو۔

فتاوی شامی میں ہے:

"ولايكلم الأجنبية إلا عجوزاً عطست أو سلّمت فيشمتها و يرد السلام عليها، وإلا لا۔ انتهى.(قوله: وإلا لا) أي وإلا تكن عجوزاً بل شابةً لا يشمّتها، و لايرد السلام بلسانه. قال في الخانية: وكذا الرجل مع المرأة إذا التقيا يسلّم الرجل أولاً، وإذا سلّمت المرأة الأجنبية على رجل إن كانت عجوزاً رد الرجل عليها السلام بلسانه بصوت تسمع، وإن كانت شابةً رد عليها في نفسه، وكذا الرجل إذا سلّم على امرأة أجنبية، فالجواب فيه على العكس (‌‌كتاب الحظر والإباحة، ‌‌فصل في النظر والمس، ج: 6، ص: 369 )

فقط واللہ اعلم بالصواب